A Boeing 747 of Pan American World Airways climbing after take-off in 1971, the year in which four caesium clocks flew around the world on scheduled airliners
Unit 06 · All masterclasses · 60 min

The Twin Paradox and Accelerated Motion

Why the travelling twin is younger, and what a rocket at g can reach
Image: Ira Ward slide, clipperarctic via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

States the twin paradox in Langevin's form and resolves it three ways: by the proper time along the two world lines, by the lines of simultaneity on a spacetime diagram, and by counting the light signals the twins exchange. The barn and pole puzzle, the caesium clocks Hafele and Keating flew around the world in 1971, and an optical clock moving at 10 metres per second follow, and the unit ends with constant proper acceleration, the relativistic rocket, and the horizon that forms behind it.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

Unit 3 showed that a moving clock runs slow, and Unit 5 drew the fact as a world line in a spacetime diagram, but both units kept every clock in one inertial frame. This unit lets a clock change frames. A twin who flies to a star and back ages less than the twin who stays at home, and the counter-argument that seems to turn the result around, which says that seen from the ship it is the home that moves, fails for a reason that can be named exactly. The same reasoning resolves an old puzzle about a long pole and a short barn, predicts what four caesium clocks did on scheduled airliners in October 1971, and gives the world line of a rocket that accelerates at \(g\) for years, a curve called a hyperbola, with a horizon behind it.

1 Langevin’s traveller

Two twins part on the Earth. One stays at home. The other boards a ship, travels at the constant speed \(v = 0.8c\) to a star \(8\) light-years away, turns round at once, and comes back at the same speed. In the frame of the Earth, which the unit treats as an inertial frame for the next few sections, the trip takes \(8/0.8 = 10\) years each way, so the home twin is \(20\) years older at the reunion. The ship’s clock is a moving clock in this frame, and by the time dilation of Unit 3 it runs slow by the Lorentz factor \(\gamma = 1/\sqrt{1 - 0.8^2} = 5/3\), so it shows \(20 \times 3/5 = 12\) years when the ship lands. The traveller comes back \(12\) years older, while the twin at home has become \(20\) years older.

The objection comes at once. Time dilation is symmetric: Unit 3 insisted that each of two inertial frames finds the clocks of the other running slow. In the ship’s frame the Earth recedes at \(0.8c\) and returns at \(0.8c\), so by the same reasoning the home twin’s clock should be the slow one, and the home twin should be the younger at the reunion. The two conclusions cannot both hold, because at the reunion the twins stand side by side, compare two clocks at one place, and no choice of frame can alter which clock shows more. This is the twin paradox. The theory contains no contradiction here; the paradox is a wrong argument, and the rest of this section says which step is wrong.

1.1 Proper time along a world line

The first resolution needs no acceleration at all, only the interval of Unit 5. A clock that travels from one event to another shows the proper time along its world line, and Unit 5 computed that proper time for a straight world line as the interval between its end points, \(c^2\Delta\tau^2 = c^2\Delta t^2 - \Delta x^2\). For a world line with a corner, the proper time is the sum over the straight pieces, and for a curved world line it is the sum over many short pieces, which the following box turns into a formula.