Einstein's Field Equations
Asks the question of November 1915: which equation links the curvature of spacetime to its content. Newtonian gravity is written in field form as Poisson's equation, the stress-energy tensor collects energy, momentum, pressure, and stress as the source, and the requirements Einstein imposed lead to the Einstein tensor and the field equations, with the constant fixed by the Newtonian limit. The unit explains why the equations are hard to solve, what it means that gravity itself gravitates, what the cosmological constant is, and how computers first solved the equations for two merging black holes in 2005.
Unit 8 ended with Wheeler’s sentence that spacetime tells matter how to move and matter tells spacetime how to curve, and Unit 9 made the first half exact: a freely falling body follows a geodesic of the metric \(g_{\mu\nu}\). The second half is still missing. Nothing so far says which metric the Sun produces, and without that rule the theory can describe motion in a given geometry but cannot predict the geometry. This unit sets up the equation that supplies it, follows the requirements that fix its form almost completely, checks that Newton’s gravity is contained in it, and ends with what it takes to solve it, by hand in 1916 and by computer since 2005.
1 Newtonian gravity as a field
Newton’s law, as Unit 1 stated it, is a rule about pairs of bodies: a mass \(M\) pulls a mass \(m\) at a distance \(r\) with the force \(GMm/r^2\). The same physics can be written as a rule about space. Unit 1 introduced the potential energy \(-GMm/r\), and dividing it by the mass of the small body gives a quantity that belongs to the point in space alone, the gravitational potential \[ \Phi(r) = -\frac{GM}{r} , \] which is negative everywhere and rises towards zero far from the mass. A body placed at any point accelerates in the direction in which \(\Phi\) falls most steeply, and the gravitational acceleration is the negative gradient of the potential, written with the partial derivatives of Unit 9 as \[ \vec{g} = -\nabla\Phi = -\left(\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial x},\ \frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial y},\ \frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial z}\right) . \] In this picture gravity is a field: a function \(\Phi(x, y, z)\) that fills space, is produced by the masses, and tells every body how to accelerate. The question that this unit asks of general relativity can first be asked of Newton. Given the matter, which equation produces the field?
The answer was found by Pierre-Simon Laplace (1749-1827) for empty space and by Siméon Denis Poisson (1781-1840) for the inside of matter, in 1813. The idea is to count how much of the gravitational acceleration points inward through a closed surface, in the way that water flowing through a net is counted: the component of \(\vec{g}\) perpendicular to the surface, multiplied by the area and summed over the whole surface, is called the flux of the field through it. For a point mass the field points straight at the mass everywhere, and the inward flux through a sphere of radius \(r\) around it is the area \(4\pi r^2\) times the field \(GM/r^2\), which is \(4\pi GM\) whatever the radius, because the area grows as \(r^2\) while the field falls as \(1/r^2\). A surface that does not enclose the mass has no net inward flux, because what enters through one side leaves through another. For a small box of volume \(V\) the enclosed mass is \(\rho V\), so the inward flux is \(4\pi G\rho V\), and a theorem of vector calculus (Gauss’s theorem, which this unit uses without proof) says that the inward flux per volume of a small box is the sum of the second derivatives of \(\Phi\), the three terms of the equation below. The result is a local equation that connects the shape of the potential at a point to the matter at that same point.
The potential of a point mass obeys Laplace’s equation outside the mass, and the check takes one line once one formula is accepted. For a function that depends on \(r\) alone, the Laplacian takes the form \(\nabla^2\Phi = r^{-2}\,\dd(r^2\,\dd\Phi/\dd r)/\dd r\), a result of vector calculus that this unit uses without proof. With \(\Phi = -GM/r\) the inner derivative is \(r^2 \times GM/r^2 = GM\), a constant, whose derivative is zero, so the Laplacian vanishes. The same formula shows that every spherically symmetric solution of Laplace’s equation has the form \(A + B/r\) with two constants, because \(r^2\,\dd\Phi/\dd r\) must then be a constant, which gives \(\dd\Phi/\dd r \propto 1/r^2\) and \(\Phi \propto 1/r\) up to an added constant. This is why the field outside any spherical body looks like that of a point mass. Inside matter the right side is no longer zero, and the example below shows what the equation then gives; Figure 1 plots the result.