Artist's impression of the star S2 passing close to the black hole at the centre of the Milky Way, with its orbit drawn as a red ellipse among the stars of the Galactic centre
Unit 11 · Advanced and Advanced + Gravitational Waves · 75 min

The Schwarzschild Solution and the Classical Tests

The metric outside a star, and the tests that Einstein proposed
Image: ESO/L. Calçada, CC BY 4.0

Presents the Schwarzschild solution of January 1916, the metric outside a spherical mass, and checks it against the weak-field limit of Unit 10. Clocks, orbits, and the effective potential follow from it, and the unit works through the classical tests: the 43 arcseconds per century of Mercury's perihelion, the 1.75 arcseconds by which starlight bends at the Sun's edge, measured at the eclipse of 1919 and today by radio interferometry, and the Shapiro delay measured with the Cassini spacecraft, together with the star S2, which repeats Mercury's test around the black hole at the centre of the Milky Way.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

Unit 10 ended with ten coupled equations and the remark that they are hard to solve. The first exact solution arrived within weeks, in a letter from the Russian front, and it describes the situation that matters most in practice: empty space around a single spherical mass, which is the Sun’s neighbourhood, the Earth’s, and the surroundings of a black hole alike. This unit writes that solution down, reads clocks and orbits from it, and puts it to the two tests that Einstein proposed, the perihelion of Mercury and the bending of starlight, then to the fourth test that Irwin Shapiro added in 1964, and finally to the star that repeats Mercury’s test around a black hole of four million solar masses.

1 The metric outside a spherical mass

Outside a star there is no matter, so the stress-energy tensor of Unit 10 vanishes there and the field equations with \(\Lambda = 0\) reduce to \(R_{\mu\nu} = 0\), which are called the vacuum field equations. They still have to be solved, and the way to solve them is to assume as much symmetry as the Sun has. Three assumptions are enough, namely empty space, spherical symmetry (nothing depends on direction, which rules out rotation, since a spinning body has an axis), and no dependence on time. Under these assumptions the ten unknown components of \(g_{\mu\nu}\) shrink to two unknown functions of \(r\), the vacuum equations become two ordinary differential equations, and their solution is the one Karl Schwarzschild (1873-1916) found in December 1915. In the coordinates \((t, r, \theta, \phi)\), with \(\theta\) and \(\phi\) the usual angles on a sphere, it reads as follows.

The first thing to check is that the solution contains Newtonian gravity. Far from the mass, \(r_{\mathrm{s}}/r\) is tiny, and the time component is \(g_{00} = -(1 - 2GM/(rc^2))\). Unit 10 showed that the weak-field limit of the field equations requires \(g_{00} = -(1 + 2\Phi/c^2)\) with the Newtonian potential \(\Phi\), and \(\Phi = -GM/r\) is exactly the potential of a point mass. The constant \(M\) in the metric is therefore the mass that a distant planet feels through Kepler’s third law, and the solution reproduces Newtonian gravity wherever \(r \gg r_{\mathrm{s}}\). What it adds is the factor in front of \(\dd r^2\), which has no Newtonian counterpart and is the curvature of space that Unit 8 blamed for half of the light deflection.

The two coordinates \(t\) and \(r\) need a comment, because they do not mean what their letters suggest. The coordinate \(t\) is the time of a clock at rest very far from the mass, where the metric becomes that of flat spacetime. The coordinate \(r\) is defined by the last two terms: a circle around the mass at constant \(t\) and \(r\) has the circumference \(2\pi r\), and a sphere has the area \(4\pi r^2\). So \(r\) is the circumference of a circle around the mass divided by \(2\pi\), and it is not the distance from the centre. The ruler distance between two spheres of coordinate radii \(r_1\) and \(r_2\) is the integral of \(\sqrt{g_{rr}}\,\dd r = \dd r/\sqrt{1 - r_{\mathrm{s}}/r}\), which is larger than \(r_2 - r_1\). Far from the mass the binomial approximation turns the integrand into \(1 + r_{\mathrm{s}}/(2r)\), and the integral of \(r_{\mathrm{s}}/(2r)\) is a logarithm, so the excess over \(r_2 - r_1\) is \((r_{\mathrm{s}}/2)\ln(r_2/r_1)\). For example, between the surface of the Sun and the orbit of the Earth the excess is \((r_{\mathrm{s}}/2)\ln(r_2/r_1) \approx 1.48\unit{km} \times 5.4 \approx 8\) km: the radial rulers measure about 8 km more than the circumferences divided by \(2\pi\) would suggest, over a distance of 150 million kilometres. Space around the Sun is curved by that much.

The full unit is part of the program

Want to see a complete unit first? Unit 3, Simultaneity, Time Dilation, and Length Contraction, is free to read.